‘I would prefer not to’.
The case of Melville’s ‘Bartleby, the Srivener: A Story of Wall Street’
Introduction
In the 19th century, before Xerox or electronic printing, important documents were copied by hand. The original Bartleby, in Herman Melville’s Bartleby, the Scrivener: A Story of Wall Street, is a copyist, or scrivener, in the offices of a Wall Street lawyer whose business it is to keep legal order in the financial affairs of his wealthy patrons. This lawyer is the narrator of Bartleby’s story.
At first, Bartleby produces a large volume of high-quality work. But one day, when asked to help proofread a document, Bartleby answers with what soon becomes his perpetual response to every request – ‘I would prefer not to.’ To the dismay of the lawyer and the irritation of the other employees, Bartleby performs fewer and fewer tasks and eventually non, instead staring for long periods of time at a brick wall just outside one of the office’s windows. Tension builds. The narrator moves not Bartleby out, bus his business – later to find that Bartleby has been forcibly removed by the new tenant and removed and imprisoned in The Tombs. When the narrator visits hem there Bartleby has died of starvation. The story closes with the narrator’s resigned and pained sigh, ‘Ah Bartleby! Ah humanity!’.
Courage and preferences
Bartleby’s story is a story of Wall Street, that is, of the walls that form the edifice of 19th century capitalism. The narrator calls himself a man of assumptions. He means he assumes everyone else accepts his assumptions. Though he does not suspect there are alternatives, he accept the values of Wall Street. For him, John Jacob Astor, slum landlord and his principal, is a model of respectability. Orderly and safe, on Wall Street, respectability means climbing to the top of the financial heap.
But for Bartleby, Wall Street means the blank wall his window looks out onto. While Wall Street assumes that competition according to the rules leads to success, for Bartleby this assumption means merely copying. Bartleby is not a man of assumptions, but a man of preferences. No one else in this story of law and Wall Street has clear preferences with regard to human life beyond the assumptions of Wall Street.
When Bartleby first defies him, the narrator says that had there been anything human about Bartleby, he would have tossed him out. From the point of view of Wall Street, Bartleby is not human, though because of Bartleby, the narrator’s understanding of what is human begins to undergo changes,.
What Bartleby possesses and the narrator lacks is self-knowledge without reference to the judgement of others. Bartleby, frail as he is, is himself. The narrator is drawn to Bartleby for reasons he can’t understand. It is as if he is drawn to something in himself he had not recognized before, something his assumptions haven’t prepared him to face.
Bartleby the scrivener is a man un-manipulated by his environment but who chooses to guide his own life and not submit to the control of others. The narrator is his opposite as Melville intends to place him – he is completely en entirely controlled by his environment.
In control of his destiny, Bartleby even deliberately chooses the time of his death.
I believe the narrator really understood the value of Bartleby and understood his courage when he declared, at Bartleby’s death, that now he was ‘With kings and counsellors’. Perhaps the narrator tolerated Bartleby’s behavior because he recognized courage in his attitude that he himself could not muster.
Inquiry into ethics
Bartleby lived in a world walled-in by human properties and the conventions governing competition. And yet Bartleby’s orbit exerts its peculiar force. Everyone has a Bartleby, someone to whom one responds for no reason the ego understands, as our narrator does to his unreasonable scrivener. What can he see in this no-account clerk? Perhaps het responds to the truth about us as it appears in Bartleby, stripped bare of any pretensions, solitary and mortal. Perhaps it is the narrator’s soul that recognizes itself reflected in Bartleby.
And we, the readers, with him.
‘Bartleby’ can be seen as an inquiry into ethics. Throughout Melville’s short story, the lawyer (and narrator) is at odds with Bartleby’s peculiar characteristics. He cannot understand his employee’s behavior and is astonished by Bartleby’s courage to refuse assignments.
Contrary to what one may expect in a situation such as this, the lawyer does not fire Bartleby. Moreover, he becomes fascinated with the employee’s courage and solitary character while still trying to coo Bartleby to work. In the end, all efforts turn out fruitless as Bartleby holds firm his resolution to do nothing.
Bartleby’s ‘I prefer not to’ is a ‘NO! in thunder’. Bartleby has the courage – out of inner urgency (and not revealed by the narrator) – to communicate his views and wishes and holds on to his sovereignty without letting himself be swayed by the opinions of others. He is defiant to do exactly what he wants and will not give in to outside forces or let his position be undermined. Despite ending up in jail and dying, Bartleby not once sacrificed his independence. No matter the costs.
To his employers orders, he does not refuse them specifically, but rather states a preference not to do them. This is a passage from a politics of ‘resistance’ or ‘protestation’, which is defined inevitably in relation to what it rejects. Bartleby’s refusal is not the start of anything, something to be subsequently overcome, but rather the primordial and ever present moment that underlies political construction. And therefore Bartleby does not simply say no to established order, a resistance which the system can always use to reproduce itself through the resistance’s participation in it, even if only negative. Bartleby walks away from the system altogether.
… and friendship (or humanism)
The narrator, contested so often by Bartleby, responds vainly or sympathetically. His vanity is that of social status and property. His sympathy is rooted in pity and Christian charity. The narrator is trapped into his own self, incapable of reacting or acting independently of any concern for how what he does reflects back upon him. What Bartleby is to the narrator is a challenge to his easy self-centeredness and a call to friendship. Bartleby is indignant because he is betrayed – but the betrayal is not that of a violation of a contract or a moral rule. It is rather the refusal of friendship, of which the narrator is incapable.
Friends do not share something – they are always already shared by the experience of friendship; friendship is the sharing that precedes all other sharing, because what it shares is the fact itself of existing, life itself. As Giorgio Agamben states: ‘The friend is not another me, but an alterity immanent in sameness, a becoming other of the same (…) Friendship is this desubjectification at the very heart of the most intimate sensation of self’ (in: L’amitié, 2007).
This sharing that Agamben writes into the heart of friendship the narrator cannot live, first because he sees and does all through his exclusive self, whereas friendship calls for a stripping down, a nakedness, of the self in a gesture of exposure, of sharing and secondly, because he is lazy and friendship requires ethical effort and courage. Bartleby displays both of these virtues, the same virtues from which the narrator can only flee, and this is het betrayal.
Final remark
‘A man has not everything to do’, states Henry Thoreau in Civil Disobedience, ‘but something’. What is this something? What has Bartleby to do? Whatever it is he feels he must do, Bartleby will not compromise. ‘Who would be a man must be a nonconformist … Nothing is at last sacred but the integrity of your own mind’, says Ralph Waldo Emerson in Self-reliance.
And the courage that comes with it, as Bartleby shows us. Taking the ultimate consequence – death – for granted.
Leo van de Voort
September 24, 2017
leo.vandevoort@courage-researchproject.com
www.courage-researchproject.com